Perspective · Sourcing

The wild-harvest problem

Beauty loves a botanical story. Behind many of them is a plant picked from the wild by someone paid very little. Biotech can help, but only if we are honest about its costs too.

Dried botanicals and plant materials on a work surface
Illustrative image

A supply chain hiding in plain sight

Many of the most loved beauty ingredients are not farmed. They are gathered. According to estimates cited by the wildlife-trade monitor TRAFFIC, between 60% and 90% of the trade by volume in medicinal and aromatic plants is wild-collected material (TRAFFIC, Wild at Home, 2018).

India is at the centre of this trade. Of the 242 medicinal plant species traded in India at more than 100 tonnes a year, 173, or 72%, are collected from wild sources (Ministry of AYUSH, 2022). Globally, one in five people rely on wild plants, algae and fungi for food and income (IPBES, 2022), and 39% of vascular plant species are estimated to be threatened with extinction (Nic Lughadha et al., 2020).

A botanical story is only as good as the field it came from and the person who picked it.

Where biotech genuinely helps

Biology can make some ingredients without taking them from a living animal or a wild plant. The best-known case is hyaluronic acid: it was traditionally extracted from rooster combs and is now mainly produced by bacterial fermentation (Liu et al., 2011). Squalene and squalane, long taken from shark liver oil, can now be made from farnesene produced by yeast fermenting sugarcane sugar (Fisher et al., 2023).

Those are real wins. Fermentation can make a material more consistent from batch to batch, less dependent on harvests and weather, and free of the pressure on an animal or a wild population.

Where it does not, or not yet

Fermentation needs sugar, and sugar needs land, water and energy. A review in Nature Sustainability found few life-cycle studies of commercial fermentation-made chemicals, and noted that claims of benefit over fossil-based chemicals often rest on climate impact alone, ignoring other impacts of growing the feedstock (Ögmundarson et al., 2020). "Made by biotech" is a production route, not a sustainability claim.

Biotech also cannot replace everything, and it should not erase the people who harvest. For many communities wild collection is income. The goal is a better wild harvest where it continues, and a better alternative where the pressure is too high, not a lab product that quietly moves the livelihood elsewhere.

Sourcing as the first question

Most sustainability work in beauty happens at the end: lighter bottles, recycled plastic, offsets. Those matter, but the decisive choice is made much earlier, when someone chooses an ingredient. We want that choice to be made with eyes open.

  1. Know if it is wild. For every botanical candidate, find out whether it is wild-collected or cultivated before anything else.
  2. Know who harvests it. Ask what harvesters are paid and how much is taken, not only whether a certificate exists.
  3. Compare routes honestly. Weigh cultivated, upcycled and fermentation routes on land, water, energy and people, not on carbon alone.
  4. Say what was measured. A sustainability claim should name the comparison and the method, like any other claim.

Anadoris Biotech is at the exploration stage and has no sourcing results to report. These are the questions every candidate we evaluate will have to answer.

Questions

How much of the botanical trade is wild-harvested?

Estimates cited by TRAFFIC put wild-collected material at 60% to 90% of the trade by volume in medicinal and aromatic plants. In India, 72% of the 242 most-traded medicinal plant species are collected from the wild.

Is fermentation-made always more sustainable?

No. Fermentation can replace animal or wild sources, but it uses feedstock, land, water and energy. Its impact has to be measured across all of these, not assumed.

Which beauty ingredients are already made by fermentation?

Hyaluronic acid, once extracted from rooster combs, is now mainly made by bacterial fermentation, and squalane can be made from yeast-fermented sugarcane instead of shark liver oil.

Sources

  1. TRAFFIC (2018). Wild at Home: exploring the global harvest, trade and use of wild plant ingredients
  2. Ministry of AYUSH, Press Information Bureau (19 Jul 2022). Medicinal plants in trade (Ved & Goraya, 2017)
  3. IPBES (8 Jul 2022). Sustainable Use of Wild Species assessment, media release
  4. Nic Lughadha et al. (2020). Extinction risk and threats to plants and fungi. Plants, People, Planet
  5. Liu et al. (2011). Microbial production of hyaluronic acid. Microbial Cell Factories 10:99
  6. Fisher et al. (2023). Organic Process Research & Development 27(12) (squalene from fermentation-derived farnesene)
  7. Ögmundarson et al. (2020). Addressing environmental sustainability of biochemicals. Nature Sustainability 3:167–174

Related

A perspective is an argument, not a study. Figures are from the sources listed, which are not Anadoris studies. Anadoris Biotech’s research is at the exploration stage: no Anadoris results or product claims are made here.

Disagree, or want to build this with us?

Start a conversation →